Tried the powder and two dish soaps today and did not get the cat. Could not figure out what went wrong. CS gave me $3.05, which was very nice, but I wanted to stock up. Just realized what the problem is/was: I had read on many places that there was trouble with the Red Apple scent, but since I had purchased many of them, figured they had fixed the problem. Apparently there are two red apple scents: Apple Mango Tango (which is what I bought before) and Apple Berry Twist (today’s purchase). So make sure you are not picking up the bad red.
Great, now I have to hit the stores again…
which explains why my store only had the Apple Berry Twist on the shelf! I also had heard that there was a problem with one of the Apple scents, so decided to wait, and after reading your post, am glad that I did!