Catsup on a Chicago hot dog!! Heresy you say? Possibly, but home-made catsup is simple to make and allows you to control sweetness and tang. Fast ’cause you’re just assembling and dumping ingredients into a slow cooker; cooker will work all day or overnight, but you’re not the one doing the cooking! Let’s start:
You will need:
Slow cooker. While you could make this on the stove, why??? sheesh!
Crushed tomatoes. Two 28 oz cans, but use what you have and adjust seasonings.
Sugar. ½ cup and can add more at the end.
Vinegar. ½ cup white vinegar; you can swap out malt, apple cider or balsamic vinegar for variety. White vinegar is what you find in the big brands.
Celery. 1 cup chopped ribs and leaves. Many recipes use celery salt, but why not use the real thing? Same goes for onion powder.
Onions. 2 small yellow onions because they were potent.
Garlic powder. ½ teaspoon, but can add more at the end.
Clove for the tang. Used 2 but they were leftovers from the Baby Jesus baby shower – use 1 if from this century.
Salt and pepper. Couple of turns on the black pepper mill and a ½ teaspoon of sea salt; better to adjust at the end.
Immersion blender, processor or blender plus funnel & strainer.
I’ve added liquids and sugar plus two sliced yellow onions already – now comes garlic powder, salt, pepper and clove.
Add a cup of chopped celery hearts (love the leaves).
Stir and cook on high for a few hours while sauce bubbles, then cover and cook on low until reduced by half (~10 hours or overnight). House will smell divine!
Sauce has cooked overnight on low (covered) and on high uncovered for a few hours this morning – see how much thicker it’s become? Let cool to room temperature and taste – I needed to add a touch more sugar and garlic powder.
I decided against both processor and stick blender since I had a lot of sauce and the Vita-Mix (my blender on steroids) will pulverize so no straining necessary. If you have a powerful blender, try it and see.
Funnel into jar and sauce into funnel.
Beautiful and extremely tasty – I can understand why people eat catsup sandwiches! Gonna transfer to a squeeze bottle, but that’s not very photogenic…