Mystery Box – White Elephant Gift Edition! Posted on November 22, 2018 by The Goddess Mystery Box – White Elephant Gift Edition! Hands down, the most fun way to participate in a gift exchange since NOBODY knows what’s being exchanged! Mystery Box comes in two levels – the $10 and/or $20 box. Obviously you’re getting way more than what you pay out! Order up to five without worrying about duplicates and shipping is one flat $4.99 rate, no matter if you’re buying one or 20.